Sowing Clover: Uruguay’s President: A Role Model for America?…by Tonya Stiles


The United States really isn’t doing well these days. You may not know it, listening to American news. You’ll still hear from the mouthpieces of every public personality that America remains the best country on earth. That, despite our current setbacks, we are still the “shining beacon” of freedom and whatnot. Of course, they offer nothing to back up this claim. No studies, or rankings, to show that living in America makes a person happier, healthier or more fulfilled than he or she would be living anywhere else. To our minds, it’s self-evident. All Americans are created better. And, of course, a corollary to the belief that we’re the best at everything is the belief that we have nothing to learn from anyone else. And we’ll continue believing it, so long as we still excel in the two arts of seduction: finance, which convinces us that money is born out of thin air and then disappears it before our eyes, and pop culture, which intoxicates us with our own vision—only prettier, happier and with greater worldly belongings.

Meanwhile, in the real world, more evidence stacks up against us. The most recent, the U.N. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean’s Statistical Yearbook, which ranked the U.S. 11th out of 19 American countries for income inequality. Some of the countries with greater income equality than ours: Venezuela, Mexico, Nicaragua, El Salvador. These Latin American countries, which were notorious through the 80s and 90s for their ill treatment of the poor and the lavish lifestyles of their wealthy, spent the last fifteen years or so lifting millions of their poor into the middle class. At the same time, in the U.S., millions of the middle class fell into poverty while we continued to reward the rich.

So who is the true “shining beacon” of the Americas? That would be Uruguay, which boasts a rating of 8.0 on the income inequality scale and a president who lives on the same income as his average citizen.

Jose Mujica.

Jose Mujica.

Jose Mujica is certainly an anomaly among world leaders. His daily life, working with his wife to tend her family’s farm, caring for flowers and chickens, is not what we’d term “presidential.” His take-home pay, under $800 a month, is enough to make him happy. The other 90% of his income he donates to charity. But even more impressive are his words. At the recent RIO +20 conference, he spoke poetically to other world leaders in a language they had likely never heard before: the language of a person more concerned with human life than with economic gain. The language of happiness, not of consumption.

Here are some excerpts from that speech, translation courtesy of a Uruguayan blogger:

I ask this question: what would happen to this planet if the people of India had the same number of cars per family as the Germans? How much oxygen would there be left for us to breathe? More clearly: Does the world today have the material elements to enable 7 or 8 billion people to enjoy the same level of consumption and squandering as the most affluent Western societies? Will that ever be possible? Or will we have to start a different type of discussion one day? Because we have created this civilization in which we live: the progeny of the market, of the competition, which has begotten prodigious and explosive material progress. But the market economy has created market societies. And it has given us this globalization, which means being aware of the whole planet.

Are we ruling over globalization or is globalization ruling over us? Is it possible to speak of solidarity and of “being all together” in an economy based on ruthless competition? How far does our fraternity go?”

Because we do not come into this planet simply to develop, just like that, indiscriminately. We come into this planet to be happy. Because life is short and it slips away from us. And no material belonging is worth as much as life, and this is fundamental. But if life is going to slip through my fingers, working and over-working in order to be able to consume more, and the consumer society is the engine-because ultimately, if consumption is paralyzed, the economy stops, and if you stop economy, the ghost of stagnation appears for each one of us, but it is this hyper-consumption that is harming the planet. And this hyper-consumption needs to be generated, making things that have a short useful life, in order to sell a lot. Thus, a light bulb cannot last longer than 1000 hours. But there are light bulbs that last 100,000 hours! But these cannot be manufactured, because the problem is the market, because we have to work and we have to sustain a civilization of ‘use and discard’, and so, we are trapped in a vicious cycle. These are problems of a political nature, which are showing us that it’s time to start fighting for a different culture.”

Listening to Mujica, one could almost imagine a world governed by his ideals—a culture which promotes the quality of living and not the ceaseless accumulation of goods. Our culture has progressed so far in the pursuit of materialism that it’s become our only export, but I like to imagine that if individual Americans could hear his words, they would be forced to acknowledge his wisdom, and perhaps something could be changed. For such a thing to happen, though, we would have to cease for a moment in proclaiming ourselves the best on earth. We would have to acknowledge that there is something to be learned from our neighbors. That, to our South, someone may hold an answer to the question, “What could make America truly great?” And that someone might be the poorest president-farmer, Jose Mujica.

Tonya Stiles is Co-Publisher of the Canyon Country Zephyr.

To read the PDF version of this article, click here.





2 comments for “Sowing Clover: Uruguay’s President: A Role Model for America?…by Tonya Stiles

  1. Scott Thompson
    April 7, 2013 at 1:36 pm

    To Americans Mujica’s simple words are striking. Perhaps jarring.

    Yet in the Middle Ages greed was seen as a deadly sin, and in Buddhism it has always been regarded as one of the “three poisons,” to be avoided by any seeker of Enlightenment.

    Whereas in America anyone NOT embracing greed as a primary lifestyle is viewed as quaintly aberrant at best (“You’re an old Hippie, Scott,” one of our local psychiatrists said to me).

    Abnormal has become normal. And vice versa.

  2. Bruce Berryhill
    April 20, 2013 at 12:03 am

    I’m a young hippie (55). I like that the peace sign is coming back. I have faith that today’s kids are getting it. Debt is not the answer to everything.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *